Daniel Carr entered guilty pleas tied to the Dec. 9, 2024 crash and to giving false information to law enforcement.
A former Townshend resident was sentenced Monday in Windham Superior Court after admitting that his driving during a slushy snowstorm led to the death of a Jamaica man on Route 30.
Daniel Carr, 36, entered guilty pleas tied to the Dec. 9, 2024 crash and to giving false information to law enforcement. Judge John Treadwell imposed a prison term of eight to 15 years, with all but three years suspended, followed by 12 years of probation.
The case centered on the death of Shane Whittaker, 24, of Jamaica, whose vehicle had left the road before he and two friends were standing beside the highway waiting for help. According to the case, Carr was driving a GMC Sierra pickup when he lost control and struck Whittaker, pinning him beneath the truck.
Carr had no valid license at the time. He later claimed that his girlfriend, who was also in the pickup, had been the one driving, a version that was eventually rejected during the investigation. Charges against the girlfriend for drunken driving were later dropped once investigators concluded Carr was actually behind the wheel.
The sentencing hearing also brought emotional testimony from Whittaker’s family. His sister, Shalba Morel, said she was nine months pregnant when her brother died and that instead of focusing on the birth of her daughter, she was preparing for his funeral. She said she saw him in the intensive care unit and described him as her closest friend.
Whittaker’s father, Shane Ballou, who is deaf and used an interpreter, told the court that the loss shattered the family and changed it permanently. He said he had gone to both the crash site and Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center.
Carr addressed the family in court and said he had tried to help after the collision, including assisting with efforts to lift the truck and helping place Whittaker into the ambulance before leaving before state police arrived.
Treadwell said the sentence was appropriate and noted that Carr would face strict supervision once he is released. A violation of those conditions could send him back to prison for at least five years.
Windham County State’s Attorney Steven Brown said the plea deal was shaped in part by evidentiary concerns, including the question of whether Carr’s conduct rose to the level of gross negligence. Brown also said Carr was not interviewed by state police at the scene because he had left before they arrived, and no test was done for drugs or alcohol.
Defense attorney Dan Stevens said the weather that day created dangerous driving conditions, with slush covering the roads. He said he was prepared to call an expert to explain that slush can make travel even more hazardous than snow.
Brown said Carr had already served 693 days in jail and hoped to live in Charlestown, N.H., after completing his sentence. Brown added that Carr is an Army veteran and hopes to find work in that area. He also said the Whittaker family supported the resolution after being kept informed about the negotiations.
Carr’s criminal history includes drunken driving, driving without a valid license and eluding police. He had also been arrested five days before the fatal crash and charged with drunken driving in what would have been his second offense.
The prosecutor said Carr should never have been driving that night and described the case as a violation of a court order with devastating consequences. Stevens noted that Monday was Carr’s birthday and said he now must figure out how to make amends for what happened.
Roadside Fires Shut Down Part of Rt 101 in Keene
Police Standards Council Moves to Strip James Lamoureux of Certification After Guilty Plea
Former Keene Property Owner Pays $510,454.44 to Resolve Federal Relief Allegations
Brief odor scare prompts evacuation at Symonds Elementary in Keene
Afghan Kebab & Grill opens in Brattleboro

Comments
Add a comment