Franklin Pierce Football Player Arrested Following Alleged Assault, Homophobic Harassment and Vandalism at Keene LGBTQ Bar

Photos: Left and Right from Madame Sherri's via Facebook depicting a photo of the damaged skeleton and the person alleged to have caused the damage, Center from Franklin Pierce University depicting the student arrested.

KEENE, N.H. — A 21-year-old Franklin Pierce University football player has been arrested following an incident outside a downtown Keene LGBTQ-friendly establishment, where a group allegedly vandalized a display belonging to Keene Pride, directed homophobic and racist remarks at employees and patrons, and repeatedly spit on a customer.

According to the Keene Police Department's arrest log, John V. Gogliettino, 21, of Hamden, Connecticut, was arrested in connection with the incident outside Madame Sherri's on Main Street. Gogliettino faces charges of simple assault and criminal mischief.

Gogliettino is listed on Franklin Pierce University's official 2026 football roster as a junior linebacker wearing number 12. The university's athletics website identifies him as a native of Wallingford, Connecticut, who previously attended Sheehan High School.

The incident reportedly occurred late Saturday night, November 14, continuing into the early morning hours of Sunday, November 15.

In a statement posted to Facebook, Madame Sherri's described a confrontation involving several individuals who allegedly began by tackling and damaging a large decorative skeleton outside the establishment.

The skeleton, affectionately known as "Skelley Duvall," belongs to Keene Pride and was preparing to receive holiday decorations when the incident occurred.

According to the business, the group damaged the display twice before the situation escalated into verbal harassment and intimidation directed at employees and customers.

Madame Sherri's alleged that members of the group made hateful, homophobic, and racist remarks toward staff and patrons. The establishment also reported that one customer was spit on three separate times during the confrontation.

The business identified one individual, described as wearing white clothing, as the primary instigator and said that person was eventually arrested. The remaining individuals were reportedly trespassed from the property.

Police records identify Gogliettino as the individual arrested in connection with the disturbance, although the publicly available arrest log does not specify which alleged actions led to each charge or identify who made the reported discriminatory remarks.

Franklin Pierce President Personally Apologizes

Following the incident, Madame Sherri's initially reported that the individuals involved were believed to be students at Franklin Pierce University in Rindge.

In a subsequent Facebook update, the business said Franklin Pierce University President Peter Eden personally visited Madame Sherri's to apologize to employees, patrons, and representatives of Keene Pride for the behavior of several students.

According to the establishment, Eden met with Madame Sherri's co-owner and Keene Pride President Adam Toepfer and indicated that the university was taking disciplinary action against students involved in the incident.

"This was a very kind gesture from the President and was not expected," the establishment wrote.

Madame Sherri's also described Franklin Pierce as a respected educational institution and emphasized that the actions of the students involved did not reflect the university's broader culture.

Details about the university's disciplinary proceedings, including whether any students have been suspended or removed from athletic programs, have not been publicly confirmed.

New Hampshire Law Provides Enhanced Penalties for Hate-Motivated Crimes

The allegations of homophobic and racist harassment raise questions about whether New Hampshire's hate-crime sentencing enhancement statute could become relevant to the case.

Under RSA 651:6, I(f), New Hampshire law allows for enhanced criminal sentences when a jury determines beyond a reasonable doubt that a defendant was substantially motivated to commit a crime by hostility toward a victim's race, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, or certain other protected characteristics.

The state has previously pursued civil rights enforcement involving anti-LGBTQ intimidation, including a widely publicized incident at the Teatotaller Café in Concord on June 18, 2023.

During that incident, members of the neo-Nazi group Nationalist Social Club, also known as NSC-131, gathered outside the café while it hosted a drag queen story hour featuring performer Juicy Garland.

According to the New Hampshire Attorney General's Office, members of the group shouted homophobic slurs, performed Nazi salutes, chanted extremist slogans, and banged on the café's windows while families and performers were inside.

The Attorney General's Office subsequently filed a civil discrimination complaint against NSC-131, its leader Christopher Hood, and other unidentified members, alleging the group's conduct was intended to pressure the café into discriminating against individuals based on sex, sexual orientation, or gender identity.

That case was resolved in July 2026, when Hood admitted that the group's conduct violated New Hampshire's anti-discrimination law. Under the resulting court order, Hood was required to pay $2,500 in civil penalties and complete 250 hours of community service. An additional $7,500 penalty was suspended contingent upon compliance with the order.

While the Teatotaller case involved civil anti-discrimination enforcement rather than criminal sentencing enhancements, it demonstrates the state's ability to pursue legal action in cases involving unlawful discriminatory intimidation.

In the Madame Sherri's incident, Gogliettino has been charged with simple assault and criminal mischief, but the publicly available arrest information does not indicate that prosecutors are seeking a hate-crime sentencing enhancement.

The allegations of discriminatory remarks alone do not establish that the legal requirements for an enhanced criminal sentence have been met.

Community Fundraising Display Targeted

The damaged skeleton is more than a seasonal decoration. It serves as part of an ongoing fundraising partnership between Madame Sherri's and Keene Pride.

The business donates one dollar to Keene Pride for each photograph taken with the skeleton and shared on social media with both organizations tagged, contributing up to $200 annually.

Madame Sherri's said it intends to repair the damaged display and return Skelley Duvall to its usual location in time for the holiday season.

The establishment described the incident as particularly troubling, saying it was the first time in approximately two and a half years of operation that staff had experienced anything of this nature.

"We know our community is better than this," the business wrote.

Despite the alleged harassment and vandalism, Madame Sherri's said the incident would not discourage its continued support for Keene Pride or the local LGBTQ community.

It remains unclear whether additional charges could be filed against other individuals involved.

Gogliettino is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.

More from Local