MILFORD, N.H. — A New Hampshire Family Court judge is facing six formal judicial misconduct charges after allegedly conducting his own investigation into a mother's criminal history, demonstrating bias against her, and providing misleading information to the state's Judicial Conduct Committee.
Judge Todd H. Prevett, who serves in the 9th Circuit Court's Family Division in Milford, is accused of violating multiple provisions of the state's Code of Judicial Conduct in connection with a 2024 guardianship case involving a mother seeking to reunite with her daughter.
According to formal charges filed October 15, the allegations stem from a December 2024 hearing in which the mother requested the restoration of her parental rights and an opportunity to begin supervised visitation with her child.
The child had been living with paternal grandparents under a guardianship arrangement established nearly a decade earlier. During the hearing, the child's guardian expressed support for a gradual reunification process, and both parties agreed to pursue supervised visitation and the appointment of a guardian ad litem.
However, Prevett denied the mother's request in a December 16, 2024 ruling, citing concerns about her credibility and past criminal history.
The Judicial Conduct Committee alleges that Prevett independently researched criminal records in New Hampshire and Massachusetts that had not been introduced during the hearing. Investigators contend that he used those records to support negative conclusions about the mother without providing her an opportunity to challenge the information.
The complaint also alleges that Prevett relied on outdated criminal matters, including three Massachusetts cases that were dismissed without convictions, while failing to adequately consider documentation of the mother's rehabilitation and recovery efforts.
Investigators further questioned the language Prevett used in his written decision, alleging that his descriptions of the mother demonstrated hostility, prejudice, and a lack of impartiality.
The New Hampshire Supreme Court overturned Prevett's ruling on July 2, 2025, ordering the guardianship case reconsidered by a different judge. The court raised concerns about whether an impartial observer could have confidence that the mother would receive fair treatment.
Following that decision, Prevett submitted information about his conduct to the Judicial Conduct Committee, which subsequently launched an investigation.
The committee alleges that Prevett provided inaccurate or misleading explanations about where he obtained certain criminal records and whether the mother had challenged his use of those records.
In one instance, investigators determined that Prevett had characterized Massachusetts criminal matters as convictions even though the cases had been resolved without convictions. In another, the committee found that his assertion that the mother had not challenged his use of outside records was contradicted by her motion for reconsideration.
The formal complaint alleges that Prevett failed to cooperate candidly with investigators and violated judicial ethics requirements governing impartiality, bias, independent investigation of facts, and honesty with disciplinary authorities.
Prevett previously maintained in his written responses that his handling of the case was legally justified and denied displaying bias or hostility toward the mother.
The six formal charges remain allegations, and no final disciplinary determination has been made in the proceeding.
The case is identified as Judicial Conduct Committee matter JC-25-058-C. View complaint.
Brief odor scare prompts evacuation at Symonds Elementary in Keene
Former NH State Representative Believed to Be Subject of Police Alert Following Reported Minneapolis Shooting
Three Injured, Roads Closed After Stoddard Head-On Crash
Proposed Hinsdale sewer hike would raise bills over two years
New Hampshire man re-indicted on murder charge in killing of his uncle
